Sugar Free Chocolate Pudding Cookies

Last year Kym over at Free Spirit Eater asked me to do a guest post on her blog for a “guilt free” dessert. I was super excited for the challenge of creating something of my own and making it healthy! It’s been a while since I shared the recipe with her readers, so I thought it would be a good time to pass it on to you guys!  

While at Target for a routine shopping trip, I happened to notice
Jello’s Sugar Free Fat Free chocolate instant pudding
mix – I thought this would be a great start: I basically just built the recipe around the pudding mix. They turned out nice and fluffy and had just the right “cakey” texture I was going for!

The first time I made these, I
tried them out on my parents and siblings who were also trying to eat
gluten free at the time and they LOVED them! My poor husband was at work while our “guests” were
enjoying these {ok, ok I may have had a few} so he didn’t get ANY! I
promised him his very own batch however, so he forgave me.

Sugar Free Chocolate Pudding Cookies
PREP TIME 5 min BAKE TIME 12-15 min


  • 2 eggs
  • 1/4 cup [1/2 stick] butter
  • 1/2 cup honey
  • 1 tsp vanilla
  • 1 small box Jello band Sugar Free Fat Free Instant Chocolate Pudding mix
  • 1 1/3 cups Pamela’s Baking & Pancake mix

Preheat oven to 350.

In medium bowl, stir together all ingredients except flour {just enough so the pudding mix won’t create a “cloud” when blending.} Next, beat the mixture on low with a hand-mixer for about 1 minute then fold in flour with spatula. The dough should be pretty thick

Using a tablespoon, scoop generous round balls {think of the measuring spoon as being the bottom 1/2 – 1/3 of your ball} on to lightly sprayed cookie sheet. These barely change their shape so don’t worry about them being too close.

Bake for 12-15 minutes {these were baked for 13.5 minutes – no I’m not crazy! This picture is actually from my second, double batch & my dad was impatient and kept checking! Sure enough, they were perfect.}

I placed ours on a cooling rack when they were done, but these are pretty much ready to eat right out of the oven! 

Kate Alyse

Kate Alyse

Kate is a proud mama to four amazing little sweeties {through birth + adoption} and wife to the best husband a girl could ask for! She considers herself blessed to be able to stay home with the kids, and is just starting to get into the world of homeschooling. In her "spare-time" she enjoys sharing many of the projects, stories, and gluten-free recipes that are a part of their every day lives!
  • These look awesome, thanks so much for the recipe! Do you think adding in oats would work at all, and would you modify the flour component for it? My husband has high cholesterol so I'm trying to find ways to incorporate more oats into our diet…

  • These look yummy!  Going to pin them as I would love to make them!

  • I don't think I would add whole oats since these are pretty cakey – the difference in texture might be a little weird. You could definitely do oat flour though! I'd probably swap 1/3 – 1/2 out with the other flour. Hope that helps 🙂

  • Those look too good!
    I'm in danger of drooling on my laptop!

    Thank you so much for sharing!
    Keep up the good work, love your blog!


  • These look amazing! I'm sort of new to the blog world, I found your blog through the b's. Here's the link to my blog

  •  Thanks! I'll be sure to check ya out 😉

  •  Awesome! You totally need to try them 🙂

  •  lol – they really are! In fact, I really think I need to get on making these again lol – it's been too long!

  • My kind of cookies. Easy, fast and chocolatey. Thanks for this recipe. By the way I think the way you and your hubby met is so adorable and total story book love. Also what do you use for your blog, I like the layout.

  • i know right?? Yes, we've definitely been very blessed 🙂 I use blogger, but I actually designed the layout myself… it's kind of slowly evolved over time 😛

share on: